Talk:All 4 One/@comment-10312571-20141101021248/@comment-1409503-20141101183511

Unfortunately, unless someone from Platinum comments on this exact instance we really have no idea what happened. We see Jeanne using different guns around the same time, whether this was intentional or not is really up in the air, but we can go off of what we know.

But if something is being assumed without official confirmation then we have to say as much on the wiki:


 * We can assume that Platinum may have made a mistake, but we don't know for certain.


 * We can assume that Rodin creates guns anachronistically, long before they're made by humans because he's Celestial/Demonic supernatural weapon smith. This goes for Rosa as well, since Remorse is four large revolvers, and the Revolver hadn't been invented yet either.


 * We can assume that Jeanne may have used the Feathers and the Cat Dolls interchangeably.

My point is, try to stick to the facts, but when you do need to put an assumption, mark it as an assumption. If you're going to contest an assumption just discuss it. Since it's an assumption both points for either view can be added to the trivia section as long as they're marked as assumptions.

In the end, the only thing that needed changing was the tidbit that feathers were added due to Jeanne's mind control, but it has been stated from Platinum that wasn't the case.