Talk:Rosa/@comment-82.26.163.161-20140922175049/@comment-1661895-20140926163425

Rosa is a special case. Because of her dialogue about Bayonetta 'inheriting' the Eyes of the World, it's possible that she used to posess the Left Eye and it was passed on to her daughter when she died. She probably also assumed that Bayonetta would inherit the Right Eye upon Balder's death as well because she was born of light and dark (though we know that's not the case). As for her unique outfit compared to the other witches, not only would her being the Left Eye fit this, but she was also imprisoned for the rest of her life after being found out to have had a child with Balder. That's why she wears all the chains and bonds around her outfit, it's like she was let free finally by the other witches when they realised they needed everyone to try and defend against the onslaught of the Witch Hunts.

So my theory would be that Rosa was the Left Eye before she was killed. But when she died, it was passed onto Bayonetta (as the Eyes must be earned rather than taken) and that's when Jeanne decided to seal her away upon figuring it out. In Bayonetta 2, it fits the circumstances in the flashback given how Jeanne was getting ready to peform the ritual just after they had found Rosa and also why Bayonetta seems shocked Jeanne stabs her out of the blue.